Past is the past and not important ~CQW
posted by: Vixen
(click the button for more info, email me if you have any great ideas for a topic, I’d love to hear from you!)
How important is the past when you enter a new relationship? Do you believe in full disclosure? Partial Disclosure? What IS important information to disclose? What is completely unimportant? Is it ok for couples to keep ‘big’ secrets from each other? Like credit-card debt, plastic surgery, criminal records???? What about reasoning behind a break up of a past relationship? I mentioned in last weeks post that some people believe this can cause greater issues. That it’s not only unnecessary but not wise to discuss each others pasts, most specifically past relationships.
I came across this:
I’ve often said… and I still believe… that a relationship is not a
deposition. Not only are you not required to answer every question
truthfully, no relationship could long survive the kind of “full
disclosure” reveal-a-thon that so many backers of “honesty” seem to
support. All healthy, lasting, long-term relationship are built on a
foundation of lies—from the outset. When you first meet someone you
don’t present your honest & true self to them, warts and all, so
that they can make an informed choice about dating you. Nope, you
present the best possible version of yourself, a sort of Potemkin
boyfriend/girlfriend ~Found HERE
Ok, whoa whoa… What?! A foundation of lies?! Would I enter a relationship and never want to ask questions and have answers regarding someone’s past- NO. I am of the mind frame that people should be honest with each other (saving feelings in certain situations is ok, kwim?), especially in a relationship. It’s a well known fact that this is how PC and I operate in our marriage AND is most likely a key ingredient in the ‘glue’ that holds it together.
Do I think every relationship *must* have full disclosure? No…..not neccessarily. But knowing about past relationships, why/how they broke up, details of your life and PAST…to me, seem pretty important! Obviously, I am quite honest, it’s how I like to be. I’m not a secretive person, it’s not who I am. I’m not GOOD at it, lol. Hell, I’m the person that is probably going to tell you waaaaay more than you want to know about me. (Seriously…)
Your thoughts?
******
~ xo
























PC
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
Says:
May 26th, 2010 at 5:12 am
I think the whole notion that coming clean or being forthright is the equivalent of a deposition highlights the underlying problem. If a couple honestly feels that volunteering details as the relationship matures is so over the top, they should end things.
It’s very true that when people intend to date, they lead with their best foot. Rarely will a couple just say, “I did this wrong, I suck at this, oh yeah I once killed a squirrel…”
But these things have to come out. They eventually will.
I once dated a girl who I broke up with me right after telling me she let her DOG do her.
I had another that broke up with me right after telling me about her fondness for cucumbers.
Did they break up with me because of their guilt? Or because my little revelations were worse?
When you and I met, we had no real interest in each other from a romantic sense. You had your interests and I had mine. Getting together and talking was like therapy. We didn’t lead with anything good. It was all bad and ugly stuff. Why? We were just friends.
And that brings me to my final point. Too many couples try to be couples first and friends second, only to realize they suck at being friends. Your interest should be to be great friends first. If something develops out of the friendship, that’s great. Run with it.
Barefoot DreamingMay 26th, 2010 at 5:43 am
I think you need to know at least the main points of the outline- the I and II and III – maybe save the a) b) and c) for a little later when a comfort level is built and then if all is still well and everyone is still comfortable include the 1) 2) and 3) ‘s
I for one would not want to be walking down the street and have a girl come up and hug my man holding a 10 month old… only to find out that was his girl and that may or may not be his baby but neither of them cares (until 3 yrs down the road blah blah when she comes looking for $) yeah – I think you need to know, or you don’t really know the person.
Professor FateMay 26th, 2010 at 8:01 am
So many things:
All healthy, lasting, long-term relationship are built on a foundation of lies—from the outset.
Bullshit! They may be build on minor deception and slight of hand, but not lies. If you try to build a relationship on the shifting sands of lies, it will fail. Maybe not today or tomorrow, but the truth has a way of coming out. What am I going to think if when I meet the fourth of your three children? The one you had when you were 15, but my math says you were 5 because you lied about your age. Not telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth on a first date (or third) is not lying. It is one of the social conventions that keep order in the world. It is pretty close, but tell her the pants are great (a lie) is much better than telling her that it isn’t that pants that make her ass look fat (a truth).
If you are going on a first dates that feel like depositions, maybe you have too much too hide or you aren’t being forthcoming enough and she has to pry details out. I tend to ask and be asked things that aren’t state secrets. What do you do? Where did you grow-up? Are you an ax murderer?
PC is right. Being friends is what can get you through the rough times. It is easy to kick a lover to the curb. It is harder to do the same with your friend.
The past is important. It has made you who you are today. Knowing about your baggage and your weaknesses are important. It may not be first date important, but if you have some Robert Downy Jr issues I need to know about them before I plan a surprise get away to eastern Europe. Knowing about your past is important because you don’t necessarily know (because I may not know) what some of my buttons are.
I may have a problem with a girl who let her dog fuck her. I may think it is really hot. Either way, that is not a first date conversation. In three years if dog fucking is a deal-breaker, I’ll walk and we’ve both wasted those years. What was a deal-breaker early in the relationship may not be later on. I may realize that you were just canine-curious and your Great Dane isn’t a threat to my manhood.
I consider trust the basis for any long-term relationship.
JeffMay 26th, 2010 at 8:08 am
I love what PC said. I would agree that all this stuff does not have to come up at the very start of a relationship but it will inevitably come up. The key then is what you do with the information when you recieve it. If your relationship is strong enough and built on a firm friendship instead of “couplehood” then you should be able to weather just about anything (except maybe someone being an axe murderer). That is why I think you should give the relationship time for these things to come out on their own. If you are communicating like you should they will eventually.
That being said, I tend to be like you, Vixen, I just throw it all out there and if you don’t like it well, fuck you!
DanielleMay 26th, 2010 at 8:11 am
I am too honest and disclose way too much also. It is who I am. As far as full disclosure, I think it depends on how well your partner can handle it. If they are mature enough then sure. If not, I probably wouldn’t date them anyway!
VixenMay 26th, 2010 at 8:13 am
PC- Well said honey :)
And you bring up a very good point about you and I and why many relationships probably fail- the friendship part. Bc you are right, when we told each other all the bad, we didn’t care what the other would think about us. So here- let me dump all the bad shit on you. LOL
Friendship first is a huge factor in a healthy relationship.
VixenMay 26th, 2010 at 8:30 am
BD- I agree. Not everything needs to be dumped on date one. But as you laid out, is a good idea.
Prof Fate- I completely agree with *EVERYTHING* you have said here. Truth IS the basis for any long-term relationship.
I also loved what you said here-
What was a deal-breaker early in the relationship may not be later on.
I think that is def. true. I’m the person that lays most likely TOO much on the line TOO soon. But I can think of many instances where something mentioned after some friendship and relationship has been developed going over better than on date one.
Thanks for your input. Always appreciate and enjoy it. :)
VixenMay 26th, 2010 at 8:32 am
Jeff- you bring up a good point
*the key being what you do with the information when you get it*
I think some people are afraid of that aspect. Which is why they with hold some information.
VixenMay 26th, 2010 at 8:32 am
Danielle- we are too similar ;)
Professor FateMay 26th, 2010 at 11:33 am
http://mingle2.com/dating/phases
The Urban CowboyMay 26th, 2010 at 11:43 am
I agree that any lasting relationship is based on friendship. I also feel that it isn’t important to go into detail when first meeting, but the major points do. It is the illusion of deception that can kill a relationship before it really gets a chance to flourish.
Sexie sadieMay 26th, 2010 at 7:14 pm
I’m with Professor Fate. BULLSHIT!
Any relationship who’s foundation is built on lies will come crumbling down upon itself sooner or later. NO relationship is sustainable in that situation.
And, I agree, friendship is the best foundation for a healthy relationship. And how do we make friends? By disclosure of personal truths which build trust and foster intimacy.
Happy Hump day!
Natisha Canalxo~Sadie
June 1st, 2010 at 9:45 am
hi,really fantastic pants,do you know where i can find that.thanks,bill